Consolations For the Self-Hating Jew

dustin-humes-q4kNNohr9cM-unsplash

It is said that the destruction of the Temple was caused because of baseless hatred, sinat chinam. The continuation of this hatred is why we arrive at the present moment, still in exile. Yet at the deepest source of a baseless hatred so timeless and intergenerational is, perhaps, the most personal kind of hatred: self-hatred, internalized antisemitism, wrought of trauma and shame. The Baal Shem Tov teaches that the greatest exile is when one doesn’t know they’re in exile at all. Who better to speak to shame than the exile of the exiles, the queer Jew? It is the Jewfag’s deep awareness of exile which may contain medicine for the old wound that haunts all of klal yisrael. Written by a queer, transgender Jewish author, this poem asks that on this T’sha b’Av, we see that pain of yearning through a lens of teshuva – return to self, return to our Maker, a return each other. Perhaps, healing baseless hatred is only possible through Ahavat Yisrael, building the world through love of what we are. Only then may we merit redemption, collective liberation, and the world to come.


 

Jewfag wears jewfailure on its skin

Jewfag has very porous skin, very

human skin, absorbs

sharpie, chemicals, glances, the word

yes, the air contains many particles

maybe that explains why a Jew

hates itself

 

“Self-hating Jew!”

Joke’s on you:

We all hate this self the same

We have all been battered and blamed

ourselves

 

Little Jew, you have no

power but the blame

takes the edge off

from no-control, stiffnecked small

nation alien inside landed nation +

how hard it is to look at our strangeness

in the face of my face

 

if you hate yourself enough

you can live the lie you shrink so invisible

they can’t kill you

if you hate yourself enough

they won’t kill you

the lie

 

come

 

little Jew

(for there are only small Jews, like

so many precious stones)

sit on my lap, in my arms

so we can look at this great

ugliness

that took root blamelessly,       not yours

not   ours

 

how you hate yourself older than you are

how it arrived imperceptibly

together, let us

look at it together

with great care

on shabbat evening perhaps, in the

darkest part of the sabbath

when twin wicks lick low

 

I will not draw the knife between us

my honor: I will not spill it, that blood

which binds us, I will not

break the blessing of this intimacy

that blessing which

binds us:

No Bad Jew

 

like a balm, please

lift up your shirt so I can whisper it in

to your porous

skin

 

it is so hard to touch the wound

it is so old it is so hard to see it

we dress it in many clothes to never

face it:

rhinoplasty, nationalism, joyless prayer

we are and we aren’t

like other people

 

come,

let me touch it

 

I cannot heal you or me

if I live only between my eyes

Rena Yehuda Newman (They/Them) is the Editor in Chief of New Voices Magazine. Rena Yehuda is a Jewish, transgender writer and comix artist, celebrating the intersections of queer and Jewish identity. They are passionate about Jewish communal memory, the power of art, Torah, and storytelling, and queering the line between the personal and political.

Get New Voices in Your Inbox!