As David Bernstein points out in this JTA Op-ed, the BDS movement which has seemed to permeate campus culture has had little to no financial ramification for Israel. For something that has been widely discussed in American Jewish circles since its inception, been the target of an Israeli law imposing financial ramifications for anyone who openly calls for a boycott of Israeli goods, it appears to have been just another load of hot air directed towards Israel. The op-ed also raises the striking question of how to advocate for Israel without being another reactionary fighting off those who would wish her harm. What are the ways to be a pro-Israel activist on campus without simply responding to allegations against her?
– Bring Israeli culture to campus. By simply showing the human side of Israel to those who might not know anything besides the exaggerated portraits painted by the media, and taking the country out of a political context by placing it in the sphere of another culture to be celebrated and enjoyed, one can foster support of Israel by simply removing oneself from the debate entirely. Paint a picture not of the embattled country seen on the news, but a vibrant Mediterranean culture attempting to grow and thrive amidst adversity.
– Facilitate conversation. Create a discussion panel for both sides of the issue, making sure everyone’s concerns are addressed. When campus discourse consists merely of two sides shouting at each other, third parties tend to be confused by the noise, and end up forming an opinion on the basis of propaganda strength. By creating a safe atmosphere where both sides may discuss their opinions, one can ease tensions and create an open conversation, rather than a battlefield.
– Don’t feel the need to jump upon every single statement. Yes, there will always be ideas you find impossible to accept, however, pick your battles, and don’t feel the need to address everything. Know the line between those who aim at eliciting a reaction and those who actually mean business, and respond accordingly. Don’t waste your time and energy defending Israel to someone just looking for an argument.
