Home
Thursday, 20 November 2008
  • Advertise
  • Links
  • About
  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • Write
  • Staff
  • Donate
  • Features
    • All Features
    • Interviews
    • In Other News...
  • Arts & Culture
    • All Arts & Culture
    • Books
    • Film
    • Music
    • Theater
    • Television
    • Art
    • Poetry
    • Fiction
    • Comic
  • News
    • All News
    • Campus News
    • General News
    • Jews in the News
  • Opinion
    • All Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Letters
    • Editor's View
  • Web Exclusives
    • Daily Features
    • Web Wire
  • Essay
  • First Person
  • Israel Correspondence
  • The Wondering Jew
  • New Vices
  • Archive
    • April 2006
mandel-120x240.gif

Current Issue

cover.jpg
button2.jpg
Nothing Secret About Crypto Jews Print
Written by Laura Kraus   
Thursday, 22 December 2005

Coming Out of the Judaic Closet in San Antonio
In an 18th-century Spanish mission in San Antonio, an odd painting dating back to the 1700s was recently discovered in the church rafters. Hidden in the background of the painting in a delicate, gold-brown hue, were the Hebrew letters yud heh vav heh: the four-letter name of God. What was the secret of the painting? No answers—but perhaps it was painted by a Crypto Jew, a Spanish Jew forced to convert to Christianity during the Spanish Inquisition.

Alternatively known as Conversos, Crypto Jews lived their public lives as Christians while secretly passing down Jewish traditions from generation to generation using clever devices. In 1580, a group of Spanish Jews fleeing the Inquisition landed in Mexico and founded what is now the state of Nuevo Leon. An inquisition of sorts also took place in Mexico City at the time, however, and many Conversos escaped persecution by fleeing to the northernmost part of the country, what is now south Texas. My ancestor Marcos Alonso de la Garza y Falcon was one of the founders of Nuevo Leon, and his descendents established their roots in San Antonio as well.

Crypto Jews are still in existence today, though many don’t know it. Their ancestors’ customs are mostly dying out, only to be discovered again by people my parents' age. My mother, who grew up strictly Catholic, remembers that her father used to only buy kosher meat "because the rabbi said so.” My great grandmother always marked the death date of her husband by lighting a candle, and on Friday nights she lit two candles. When asked about the candles, she explained that her mother had done so, as had her grandmother.

In Downtown San Antonio’s Mercado, or marketplace, pan de Semita is for sale. This “Semitic bread” is basically a Mexican form of matzah usually eaten during Lent. The Mercado is full of men gambling with dreidel-like tops inscribed with instructions on the sides written in Spanish: take all, take half, take nothing, and give one. In the poor parts of town, chickens roam the yards and are butchered by tan grandmothers who hang the headless bodies upside down on a clothesline until the blood is all gone. Before cooking, they rub the meat with salt to cleanse it.

Sometimes, the lucky ones of my mother's generation got an answer for these rituals: "Somos Judios,” we are Jews. But the need for secrecy still held, and they were sworn not to tell anyone outside the house. Then in the 1980's, people started coming out of the Judaic closet. Many communities in New Mexico can now prove their genetic heritage, and almost all the males of one such community tested positive for the Cohen gene.

Still, many Orthodox Jews still do not believe that they are their spiritual brothers. The Chief Rabbi of Mexico argues that these people were the servants of Jews who did not convert. I know a woman in San Antonio with Crypto Judaic heritage who was denied a conversion: the traditions were there, the local Orthodox rabbi told her, but the proof wasn't.

However, my teacher, Rabbi Samuel Lerer, converted over 3,000 Crypto Jews in his lifetime. He is now buried in Mexico City with his beloved congregation that he fought so hard for. His heir to the Crypto Judaic cause, Rabbi Jacques Cukierkorn of Kansas City, is eager to surpass the 3,000 mark set by Rabbi Lerer. He has at least two under his belt: he converted my mother and me last year (my father is an Ashkenazi Jew).

Of all my studies of Crypto Jews, the one thing that surprises me the most is how Crypto Jews seem to unknowingly gravitate towards Judaism. Many personal accounts talk of how people who grew up "not feeling right" in the faith in which they were brought up are suddenly turned on when they encounter Judaism. Like the painting in Mission Concepcion, it seems as if one’s heritage is always at play beneath the surface. My mother and I are just two of the many Crypto Jews who are unearthing and embracing our roots every day. Our identity is no longer hush-hush.
Comments
Add NewSearch
Crypto Jews, Indeed?!
Lauro Antonio Garza (66.118.49.xxx) 2008-06-21 21:40:35

Laura, I am very much afraid that you have been duped like so many others by a collection of non-sense supported by one book by Rafael that has yet to be properly vetted by the scholastic community. I have spent decades researching the De la Garza heritage and have found no evidence of the "Jewish" heritage spoken of now so firmly, as though it was common knowledge. The descriptions of avoidance of pork and blood in the food production that has been noted by a amateur historian named Robinson is just so much non-sense! He spoke of tortillas being unleavened bread and that was proof of the jewish heritage! What utter non-sense. You might as well take about lights in the sky being UFO's! Tortillas are made with pork fat and Mexicans, including Garzas, have been eating blood sausage and blood soup since time eternal! The Garzas and the Trevino's descend from Marcos Alonso De la (G)Arza y del Arcon and Alonzo is not a jewish surname as some would assert! It is simply a christian name.

The Garza went on to found churches and engage in every Catholic sacrament that has ever been employed since the records were kept. That's how I was able to connect the dots, so to speak, for the last 450 years. They were entrusted with leadership and government positions throughout the centuries, do you honestly believe they would have enjoyed such success if they were suspected of being jews?
What I'm telling you is this is a great hoax! I'm not telling you not to be a jew nor am I suggesting that you change your attitudes about any religion, but I am saying that I think you should not spread this non-sense any further.

I've been getting emails from Mexico, Texas and even Austrailia referring to the Jewish Garzas all emenating from the Rafael book. It's just plain BS. Don't believe it.
Reply
Re: Garza
Laura Kraus (216.188.248.xxx) 2008-09-11 22:05:07

Dear Sir:

I take high offense to your ripping apart my article because of the sole mention of one of my ancestors. Although I appreciate your feedback and will refrain from spreading this "non-sense" about my ancestor any further, I will continue to believe that certain customs of the Crypto Jews exist in South Texas.
I do wish you would direct me to this "Rafael" book as I have never heard of it. I also suggest you contact Mr. Harry Stein of Sephardim.com and tell him of this egregious error on his part, because he has your familial name listed as one of those dirty marranos. However, if I were you I would be more polite to him as he will probably not respond as kindly as I have to your overreactions.
Once again, I apologize for upsetting you so.

Sincerely,

Laura Kraus
Reply
The Myth of the Crypto-Jews
Lauro Enrique Garza (98.198.220.xxx) 2008-07-26 20:23:28

Lauro Antonio Garza I agree totally with your statements as to the myth of the Jewish origins of the Garzas. I wrote an article for the Hispanic Genealogical Society Journal of Houston, Texas that contained a section to debunking the story. One hard fact there never has been a synagogue in any of the towns of Nuevo Santander,from Matamoros to Guerrero! I am 9th generation Garza from Starr County Texas, please tell me how you got the name Lauro. It was my grandfather and father's name as well.
Lauro Enrique Garza
Reply
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
Security Image
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
Powered by !JoomlaComment 3.12

Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved.



 
[ Back ]
This website was made possible by a generous grant from Targum Shlishi, a Raquel and Aryeh Rubin Foundation.