The War at Home Print E-mail
Written by Richard Frederic Semegram   
Tuesday, 05 February 2008

Fuel For Truth Brings Israel Advocacy to the Nightclub. What Kind of Party Is This, Anyway?

Image
Revelers at a Fuel For Truth event in Manhattan.
Before Terry Schappert took the stage, the scene on June 14th at New York City nightspot Arena was much like any other Midtown party. Well dressed young men and women packed the club, drinking and flirting under the tinted lights. About an hour and a half after the velvet rope parted, however, the music faded and Schappert, a square-jawed former Special Forces sergeant, approached the microphone. Overhead, a projection screen showed a red and blue outline of America under crossed rifles and the words “Behind Enemy Lines.” According to an account printed the following week in the New York Sun, Schappert told a rapt crowd, “Our enemies are fighting an information war with us...a war to convince us that we are the cause of terrorism.” A strange message, perhaps, for a mid-party lecture. For Schappert and the event’s hosts, an Israel advocacy organization called Fuel For Truth, that was exactly the point. The speech was a sword of Truth sheathed in a cocktail napkin.

Israel advocacy is a traditionally un-hip cause, lacking the cachet enjoyed on campus by pro-Palestinian activist groups. Fuel For Truth, a non-profit based in New York City, aims to change that by dressing up a straightforward pro-Israel message with cool-kid party hype and militaristic imagery. Through events targeting 18-34 year-olds, the group constructs a preppy subculture where it makes perfect sense to listen to a speech on the threat of radical Islam while standing on the dance floor of a darkened nightclub.

In the Club
Image
Fuel For Truth's logo.
Since its founding in 2001, Fuel For Truth has sought to “gather and disseminate accurate information about Israel and the Middle East,” according to the group. The content of their message is standard pro-Israel fare. A list on their website of the “Top Ten Facts About the Middle East" includes the usual talking points: Israel is a democracy, Palestinians rejected the Oslo accords, and so on. The packaging, however, is revolutionary.

“We are, as a generation, very social,” says Kat Guttman, director of operations at Fuel For Truth. “We get information from our peers, more than from the news [media]. We get it from our social networks.” To access and influence these networks, Fuel For Truth hosts social events that Guttman optimistically describes as the “the best parties in New York City.” The events, such as the June party at Arena, are held at clubs throughout New York, and are organized around themes such as, "Behind Enemy Lines: What Radical Islam Doesn't Want You to Know," and "FFT Fight Night: Hamas vs. FFT." Yael Gross, a Fuel For Truth member and organizer, describes how “people crowd in...there are always a few celebs photographed in the front.” The party features a half hour slide show filled with easily digestible “facts” about Israel and the War on Terror. Says Gross, “We basically lure them in, kind of 'scare' them or 'shock' them with images and facts that they didn't know...then tell them what they can do to help out and after that the party goes on!”

The group also hosts a series of campus parties. A recent press release describing one such event at Columbia University explained that the discussion at a popular bar would “stir in facts using a rapid fire briefing style reminiscent of the TV show 24 to get across the critical data about Israel, the Mid-East Conflict, and why it is so important for young Americans to be informed.”

Behind the Shield
For most participants, a party and a few sound bites are all of the engagement that Fuel For Truth offers. Each year, however, a few young people are allowed to go further. Attaining full membership in Fuel For Truth is a rigorous and selective process. “The most direct path to membership is to attend our 10-week Boot Camp,” says Guttman. The Boot Camp accepts 20 people a year, teaching them “the history of Israel, Judaism, Islam, and Christianity,” according to a video on the Fuel For Truth website. While participants are allowed to keep their day jobs, the program involves evening classes, readings, homework, and event organizing experience. At the end of the program, graduates undergo an induction ceremony in which they gain the right to wear on their lapel Fuel For Truth’s logo: a blue shield bearing a large Star of David in the center with a smaller crescent and cross in the lower corners.

According to Guttman, the casual militarism is anything but accidental. Although she maintains that Fuel for Truth considers itself to be a “democratic, for peace organization," she continues, "We like to be known as a fighting army, with truth as our weapon.” This informs a range of the group's activities, including former military men as speakers, as well as referring to student organizers of campus events as “Fuel For Truth’s Special Forces of Israel Advocacy.”

Spreading the Message
In the six years that Fuel For Truth has existed, the organization has spread its message to thousands of people in the unaffiliated, assimilated, young urban demographic that the group targets. According to Guttman, they focus on politically unaffiliated and socially influential individuals. Joe Richards, the group’s founder, targeted this particular bracket after deciding that it was being left behind by advocacy groups and was susceptible to the influence of the media and ill-informed peers. In spite of the commonly cited apathy of the Internet Age, Richards believed these young people could be reached.

Frank Luntz, the political pollster best known as the Republican party communications guru who named the “death tax,” conducted a survey this past March of Fuel For Truth’s members and participants. “Members are advocating on behalf of Israel eight more times a month versus young people who do not participate in Fuel For Truth,” according to Luntz. The survey also found that 47% of those involved with Fuel For Truth are “more interested in Judaism” than they were before they joined. “Apparently, a byproduct of Israel advocacy is an interest in the religion behind the country,” Luntz says.

Not all advocacy is good advocacy, of course. Fuel For Truth’s efforts to convey what they believe to be the basic truths of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in a format that goes down easy are typical of an age in which in-depth understanding of current events is too often replaced by a set of entertaining factoids. While the facts that Fuel For Truth purports may be well-researched, their rhetoric of Truth implies an unwillingness to engage in dialogue. When coupled with the militant affectations of the organization’s elite members, such an attitude inspires some concern. Behind the veneer of glossy photo shoots and frenetic messages, Fuel For Truth is structured to breed a sort of certainty not conducive to healthy debate.
Comments
Add NewSearch
Right on
Jason (96.232.29.xxx) 2008-02-06 10:42:27

I was at that event last summer! They know how to get the message across.....and have a good time doing it.

Good crowd. Not your typical Jewish-nebbishy peeps too. Finally!!
FFT was at my school
Sam Rosen (96.232.29.xxx) 2008-02-06 10:50:14

I was a junior at Binghamton University when they came up to my campus last year. NOT what we expected of a Jewish group. They were cool, smart, and hot. We got to hang with them all weekend and they really made me and my friends care about something we never cared about before- Israel rocksss. If anyone from FFT is reading this, COME BACK- WE WANT MORE.
JW (207.162.229.xxx) 2008-02-06 10:51:40

Arena was awesome! Next event is coming up on March 20th! Don't miss it!
Reader (72.225.234.xxx) 2008-02-07 21:51:49

One wonders if the previous commenters actually read the article...
ex-zionist (76.205.69.xxx) 2008-02-08 08:08:18

a perfect illustration of how desperate the self-styled "israel-advocates" are becoming. young people are increasingly pro-palestinian because we're too sophisticated to be fooled by simplistic propaganda. the pro-palestine and peace groups put on substantive, sophisticated events that may have little flash but are compelling and realistic. the "israel advocacy" crowd either presents fools like daniel pipes or alan dershowitz, or else relies on slick propaganda that doesn't fool anybody who's got good judgment. i took great pleasure in watching a young man in a kippah grimace as he was handing out postcards of scantily clad women to illustrate israeli "liberalism" and "hipness." bottom line, israel is going to continue to attract critics until its alleged advocates start acknowledging and addressing the reality of what israel is and what it's doing.
MW (205.188.117.xxx) 2008-02-08 12:21:34

To ex-Zionist up above, it is a damn good thing Fuel For Truth is experiencing such great success. People such as yourself have been drawn into the Pro-Palestinian Propoganda machine with terrorists pushing your buttons. "Bottom Line" - The (Real) Truth wins everytime. Wake up...before it is too late for you.
cultural/labor/socialist zioni (68.54.94.xxx) 2008-02-08 22:32:46

I've got to agree with the ex-Zionist. The standard in the jewish community is to support Israel no matter what. It is unfortunate that so many people would rather use flashy means of convincing others that Israel is flawless than address the flaws that exist. This type of Israel advocacy is the opposite of Tikkun Olam. Rather than repair Israel people would get college kids to associate it with booze.
FFT vs. anti-Zionist Jews, who
reuven (129.64.164.xxx) 2008-02-09 11:20:04

No matter whether they turn you on or off (I haven't met them so I won't pass judgment), FFT is a reactionary force. Their message only came about in response to the arguments of those who demonize Israel. Oh and if they give off the impression that they'll kick your ass, they actually will. Lucky for those of you keeping score from the sidelines of Jewish society, your anti-Zionism is protected speech. As such it probably wouldn't last in a bare-knuckles bout for survival, but you wouldn't know anything about that, would you?
SSDD
B.BarNavi (68.50.163.xxx) 2008-02-10 12:49:16

What this amounts to is, once again, pure PR. Instead of trying to fix Israel's problems, this program and its allies once again distract by painting critics of Israel as anti-Zionist Jew-haters. If this energy and effort were ever spent constructively...

Also, I'm kinda intrigued that (if Luntz's words are taken to be true) these kids are becoming interested in Judaism in such an un-tznius way...
The Perpetual Anti-Zionist Jew
Jack Garbuz (96.224.141.xxx) 2008-06-30 18:59:13

From the very get go,at the turn of the 20th century, there were many bleeding hearts seeing the presence of a few hundred thousand Arabs subsisting on our ancient soil, that said we Jews were simply out of luck. Too late. Already people living there. And so, 9 million Jews, many stateless for centuries, being kicked and having to wandering from country to country - including from Russia to the US - would forever have to give up their hopes for self-determination and sovereignty so that a few hundred thousands Arabs might not have to move over just a little bit to be accommodating. The Leftist Jews are very good to everybody except their own tribe.
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
Security Image
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved.


 
< Prev   Next >