The Conspiracy

J Street U: A plea from a mabat chitzoni

This post is by Moriel Rothman and originally appeared on J Street U‘s site.

There exists in Israel a powerful fear. It’s a legitimate fear, the traumatic societal residue of exploded buses and falling rockets, hitting Israel against the backdrop of the Iranian threat. But this fear has grown and spread, manipulated by leaders whose pursuit of security has made Israel far more insecure. Israel’s most powerful threat is not a boat full of angry activists or a community of hateful bloggers. Israel’s most powerful threat is not Syria or Hamas or Hizbullah or even Iran. Israel’s most powerful threat–and Defense Minister Ehud Barak agrees–comes from the lack of progress toward a two-state solution and peace.

An Israeli friend told me recently that my mabat chitzoni, or outside perspective as an American, prevented me from understanding the conflict. Perhaps he was right: maybe I don’t understand why Israel blocks certain foods and toys from going into Gaza because of my mabat chitzoni. Maybe that’s why I don’t get how Israel’s policy of forbidding exports from Gaza helps prevent imports into Gaza. Maybe it’s my mabat chitzoni that sees the blockade failing to accomplish any of its possible strategic goals: facilitating the release of Gilad Shalit, encouraging the people of Gaza to rise up and overthrow Hamas or stopping rockets from coming into Gaza. So maybe I wouldn’t have been disturbed by the events on the Mavi Marmara–carried out in order to defend a strategically backwards and morally bankrupt blockade–had it not been for my mabat chitzoni.

Where are the statements of remorse for the lives lost?  Where are the statements of concern for the children of Gaza? Not for the leaders of Hamas, and perhaps not for those who voted for Hamas, but for the children. Have we so hardened ourselves that we’re unable to feel pain for any but our own? How much will the other side have to suffer for the blockade to end?

So perhaps it’s my mabat chitzoni that fails to see any way for Israel to remain a Jewish, democratic homeland unless there is a two-state solution and a negotiated peace agreement with the Palestinians. Perhaps my mabat chitzoni can’t imagine the international community continuing to support Israel’s occupation and blockade. Perhaps my mabat chitzoni enables me to see the Palestinians as human beings who deserve food, water, safety, freedom of movement and independence. Just like us.

Israel is mired in a spiral of violence, fear, hubris and confusion. Some argue that it is not appropriate for those approaching the issue from a mabat chitzoni to criticize, challenge and meddle. And if Israel were only hurting itself, this argument might be compelling. But Israel is not only hurting itself, Israel is hurting the Palestinians -who also continue to hurt themselves and the Israelis in a myriad of ways. Moreover, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict hurts the potential for international stability and peace. It is not only appropriate, but obligatory, for those of us with a mabat chitzoni to criticize some of Israel’s actions. The American mabat chitzoni, coupled with the US’s international power and its strong alliance with Israel, is crucial to securing Israel’s future. Obama must live up to the promises he made one year ago in Cairo, and bring peace to the Middle East. As much as it pains me to criticize my brothers, it would pain me more to leave them alone.

Moriel Rothman was born in Jerusalem, Israel. He is the new President of the National Student Board of J Street U, and is a rising senior at Middlebury College, in Vermont.


Tags: , , , , , , ,

One Older Response to “J Street U: A plea from a mabat chitzoni”

  1. David Stein
    June 9, 2010 at 3:31 pm #


    Your point is interesting but misguided. I am not sure if you are an American citizen but as an American citizen, the US Government who was elected by the people of the US, is charged with protecting its citizens. They are charged with providing all the necessary means to keep their citizens safe. The government elected by those in the Gaza Strp is Hamas. Why are you not critisizing Hamas for not caring for their constituents? Your views are truely selfish. Because I presume that if your University was being bombed by the British Navy you would want the US to protect you and do everything in their power for rockets not to be fired at your apartment. Right? Where would you rather live, in a place that has limited resources or place where you might die due to a rocket any minute of the day?

WordPress Backup
Read previous post:
WTF, Helen Thomas?

Unless we're seeking an easy target for righteous indignation, we tend to ignore the mass of anti-Semitic crackpots on the internet....